Mechanical Keyboard Vs. Membrane Keyboard: What are the main differences?

In the world of computer keyboards , two types of keyboards compete for the spotlight: mechanical keyboards and membrane keyboards . Each of them has specific characteristics and offers very distinct user experiences.

In this article, we will explain the differences between mechanical keyboard and membrane keyboard . This way, you can make an informed choice based on your needs and typing style.

How are mechanical keyboards and membrane keyboards designed?

Mechanical keyboards are distinguished by the use of individual mechanical switches under each key. These switches are made up of several parts, including a spring, a metal contact and a pusher. When you press a key, the spring releases and the pusher touches the metal contact, registering your keystroke.

The tactile sensation you feel when typing on a mechanical keyboard will depend on the switches used, also called switches . These switches vary in resistance: some require more force to press, while others are softer. This diversity of switches allows everyone to choose the typing sensation that precisely matches their preferences.

On the other hand, membrane keyboards use a simpler mechanism. Under the keys, we can find a rubber or silicone membrane with domes or pads. When you press a key, the membrane depresses, creating an electrical contact, which registers the keystroke. The main advantage of the membrane keyboard is its simplicity, which generally makes these keyboards more affordable to produce.

Typing feel and noise level: What differentiates mechanical keyboards from membrane keyboards?

The typing feel is one of the most notable aspects that sets these two types of keyboards apart.

Thanks to their design, mechanical keyboards offer superior responsiveness . The sharp activation point allows for instant response, which is essential in situations where speed and accuracy are essential, such as in competitive gaming or for intensive text or data entry

They are also popular for their audible tapping sensation due to the mechanical switch design. Therefore, the choice of switch for your mechanical keyboard will have an influence on the sound level and the feeling when typing.

If you want to know more about the advantages of having a mechanical keyboard , do not hesitate to consult our detailed article: What is the point of having a mechanical keyboard?

Membrane keyboards , on the other hand, offer smoother typing but with less pronounced and less precise tactile feedback . The limbed design is quiet when typing, making it an ideal choice for shared workspaces.

Mechanical keyboard Vs. Membrane keyboard: which one is more resistant?

The third difference between mechanical keyboards and membrane keyboards is durability . And the big winner is….

… The mechanical keyboard , renowned for its exceptional longevity!

Indeed, mechanical switches can withstand millions of keystrokes, ensuring reliable long-term use . They also have the advantage of being very easily repairable since the switches are easily changed. Its robustness therefore makes it a preferred choice for those looking for a long-term investment .

Membrane keyboards , while less expensive , tend to be less durable . The conductive rubber layer can wear away over time, leading to decreased key responsiveness and more frequent replacements.

Advanced Customization Vs. Simplified Customization: Which Keyboard Suits Your Needs?

When it comes to customization , mechanical keyboards and membrane keyboards still have differences .

If you are looking for a 100% personalized typing experience , then the mechanical keyboard is an ideal choice . Choose the switch that best suits your preferences and needs in terms of feel and typing sound. For this, we have prepared a complete guide to help you decide which switch to choose for your mechanical keyboard .

In addition to switches , you can also personalize a mechanical keyboard by modifying the RGB backlighting or the layout of the keys . Or, you also have the option of building your mechanical keyboard piece by piece .

On the contrary, if customization is not a crucial criterion for you, then membrane keyboards are more suitable. In fact, the customization possibilities are more restricted since the settings are limited to simple adjustments, with less advanced backlighting. However, their use remains simple and functional , which is ideal for those looking for a practical and economical option .

Conclusion

The choice between a mechanical keyboard and a membrane keyboard will depend on several factors. These factors include intended use, durability and typing experience preferences, and budget.

If simplicity , smooth typing and lower budget cost are essential criteria for you, then we recommend choosing a membrane keyboard that will perfectly match your needs.

On the other hand, if you are a video game enthusiast , a programmer , a creative , or an intensive data or text entry professional , then we recommend opting for a mechanical keyboard . You will appreciate its precision , its responsiveness and its multiple customization options . If you want to know more about the reasons to choose a mechanical keyboard , we have put together a detailed article on this subject: Why choose a mechanical keyboard?